I think the reason they need to do that is they have so many children they can't travel by apparition and they used it to convey their social status by not being able to afford other means of travel. 9 They Are Pure Bloods. Arthur's job doesn't make a lot of money. Weasleys are not poor, they are pariahs. Published Sep 16, 2020. Why are the Weasleys poor? More general. This is obvious from the beginning when Ron appears with his wrapped sandwiches and his hand me down robe. There really shouldn't be any need for money when . They've probably got vaults stuffed with galleons at Gringotts. During Christmas in Harry's second year Mr and Mrs Weasley embark on a cross-continental trip to visit Bill in Egypt. Ministry of Magic: Department of Misuse of Muggles Artifacts Office & Office for the Detection and Confiscation of Counterfeit Defensive Spells and Protective Objects. Well, this is the Ministry . 2 yr. ago. I understand they're poor, but if they are poor why did they have so many children? Magical textbooks presumably have anti-copying Charms on them, and no number of Repair Charms will make robes look completely new, but other than that a magic-capable adult is not in poverty on a cosmopolitan level. Harry found it peaceful, rather than gloomy, and enjoyed the fact that he, Hermione and the Weasleys had the run of Gryffindor Tower, which meant they could play Exploding Snap loudly without bothering anyone, and practice dueling in private. The Weasley family should not be as poor as they are. It's rare to have a family of blood traitors, as they'd have to not value . Rich Wizards, Poor Muggles This does not seem relevant to me. 20. All right, I guess that's okay. It had a separate entry for each problem (and there were dozens of them identified) and went into several paragraphs of detail . The dirt is from using the floo. A couple of years ago I found a great blog that went into extensive detail about the major problems with plot and worldbuilding in the Harry Potter books, but I can't seem to find it again. That's one of the five exceptions to Gamp''s Law of Elemental Transfiguration. However, many fans have questioned just how the red-headed goof inexplicably shares the spotlight with Harry Potter and Hermione Granger throughout the core of the adventures. Blood, sweat, and tears in Naomi Novik's Scholomance novels. Until Bill and Charlie started working, the Weasley family had one earning member to take care of the household expenses, education and upbringing of 9 family members. . Remember Ron used to have only second hand stuff (clothing . The Weasleys are poor for wizards, but they have a large house, plenty of food and live comfortably. All the more with magic. Not so much why people don't have to work, but why everyone isn't fantastically rich by Muggle standards. Hufflepuff. Arthur Weasley is both a softie and a badass. What annoyed her . The Weasley family is featured throughout the "Harry Potter" series. Why would any wizard be? Answer: You can't conjure food. But only half. If they telephoned or used the internet, there would be no need for owls. There would be a huge rise in owl unemployment and the place would be riddled with owls hanging around and hooting menacingly. 9 The Weasleys Shouldn't Be Poor. It covers why there are rich and poor wizarding families, but not what they do with their money. The short explanations are: * Fred. For example, McGonagall turns a desk into a pig. He cited his love and infatuation with muggles as their reasons for being poor. It makes sense that the Weasleys were a pureblood family, what is interesting is that they are still a pure-blood family by the time Harry meets them. It is also clear that some Weasley's were incredibly well off because Aunt Muriel had such a large house that she could accommodate all the Weasley clan during DH when they went into hiding. They might also be poor because the local economy has collapsed due to the influence of a person with an economically disruptive talent. Why are the Weasleys poor? Jan 28, 2020. Answer (1 of 21): The following reasons - 1. As for the clothes, I guess in my mind I have always assumed there is only . The surname holds a special meaning, and some of their first names are . Percy Weasley devoted himself to the ministry, choosing to side with those who denounced the return of Voldemort rather than his own family. Was it because Molly wanted a girl? Answer (1 of 4): I have wondered this myself. Naomi Novik began her series of fantasy bildungsromans, in part, because she found Harry Potter extremely irritating. #1. . Conclusion 9 yr. ago. The Weasley family went bankrupt. The Weasleys being known as a blood traitor family predates Arthur - Cedrella Black, who'd have to have been born between 1915 and 1919 based on her elder and younger sisters' birth years, was blasted off the tree for marrying the blood traitor Septimus Weasley. 19. The low opportunity cost attached to magic spills over into the thoroughly unbelievable wizard economy. There's simply a lot of them (even those who aren't notorious troublemakers), and that puts a strain on a. Answer (1 of 8): What does "poor" even mean in a society when you can magic up half of what you need? 13,845. True, Gamp's law says you can't conjure food, but actually people do conjure food. They have always been poor. He is one of the most lovable parental figures of The Harry Potter Series because of his acceptance of himself and his . There are pure blood families that are old money, the Weasleys seem to be so almost accidentally. Molly's brothers were killed in the First Wizarding War, and Arthur is related to the Blacks. They might've taught that the map is just wrong, since Wormtail is a part of the Marauders. 6 Blamed Arthur For Money Troubles. . The Weasleys were poor. They've been blood traitors and fought in the First Wizarding War and yet, despite marriages across the family, they still hold their "pure blood" status. I think the Weasleys like being the way they are and don't want to change. On a Reddit post, u/OutOfStamina pointed out that it made no sense for the Weasley family to be as poor as they are, especially given the way magic works in that particular world. * George. Then there were those times he needed a hug. It may also be the case that the Weasleys are having the misfortune of living through a time of war and chaos. The Weasleys are featured throughout "Harry Potter," but it's easy to lose track of these facts. With magic . I'm sure Hogwarts does not cha. In Xanth, the Weasleys may be poor because they have fairly worthless talents. The Weasleys are poor because of having 7 children. Then you got older and started questioning some of J.K. Rowling's fictional economic systems or the lack thereof. It makes no sense for the Weasley family, which is full of capable witches and wizards, to be poor when they have magic. Food isn't the main issue for the W. They're definitely never hungry, as Molly ensures, but why not use magic for anything else they need, including home repairs and renovation? Nor does it explain why some wizard families choose to "live poor" in muggle terms when they don't have to. In her defense, she did admit that that aspect of world-building is not her strongest suit. Warner Bros. Harry Potter's Wizarding World is a place full of wonders and joy and something you could enjoy without much suspension of disbelief while you were younger. * The Weasleys, plural. Harry Potter's Arthur Weasley wasn't always the bravest man, but he had his fair share of badass moments. But even more, Percy blamed his father, Arthur, for being poor. They have their own families and they will, of course, meet each other during the holidays. There's nothing shameful about Ron Weasley. No, they're also conventionally poor. Ronald Weasley; Ginny Weasley; Albus Dumbledore; Lord Voldemort; Neville Longbottom; Draco Malfoy; . All you can do magically with food is transfigure it to something else, multiply it, and Summon it (or otherwise transport it) from another location. Anything they need, except scarce magical objects, can be obtained by ordering a house elf to do it, or casting a spell, or, in a pinch, making objects like dinner, or a house, assemble . Ron Weasley isn't quite the "red-headed step-child" of the Harry Potter franchise that some make him out to be. Why is the family referred to as . Their thrifty, frugal lifestyle is a sign of them saying "fuck you" to the type of lifestyle and status obsesssed mentality of the purebloods. On a Reddit post, u/OutOfStamina pointed out that it made no sense for the Weasley family to be as poor as they are, especially given the way . So, I guess, some of the family does have money (old money I would say).

How Long To Spend On Great Barrier Island, How To Execute Chest Pass In Basketball, What Is Diffuse Axonal Injury, How To Unlock Yubel In Duel Links, How Many Days Until November 1 2022, How To Complain About Neighbors Garbage, What A Wonderful World!, How To Take Blurry Photos Canon, What Nationality Is Roger Federer,